All Good People Here Book Review, novel by Ashley Flowers

All Good People Here: Book Review Synopsis

“All Good People Here” by Ashley Flowers is a propulsive debut novel set in the small town of Wakarusa, Indiana. The story follows Margot Davies, a big-city journalist haunted by the unsolved murder of her childhood neighbor, January Jacobs. This infamous case shook the community and has remained a cold case for years.

Twenty years after January’s death, Margot returns to Wakarusa to care for her sick uncle, Luke, who is suffering from early-onset dementia. Her return feels like stepping into a time capsule, with the town unchanged but simmering with old secrets and unresolved tensions. Margot’s career as an investigative journalist is already on shaky ground, and her return to Wakarusa only intensifies her need to find answers.

The story takes a dramatic turn when news breaks of the disappearance of another young girl, five-year-old Natalie Clark, under eerily similar circumstances to January’s case. Margot, driven by old feelings and her journalistic instincts, vows to solve both Natalie’s disappearance and January’s murder. Her investigation reveals a tangled web of deceit, where the townspeople, police, and even Natalie’s family appear to be hiding something.

Margot’s investigation leads her to confront the hometown’s dark secrets, which are intricately woven through dual timelines and multiple perspectives, including January’s mother, Krissy Jacobs. Margot’s quest becomes increasingly dangerous as she uncovers misleading clues and receives ominous threats. The suspense builds as she is followed by a mysterious woman, and her dedication to the case causes her to lose her job and puts her own life in peril.

This searing tale delves into themes of fear, justice, and the lengths to which people will go to protect their loved ones. Ashley Flowers, also known for her work on the true crime podcast Crime Junkie, brings her expertise in crime storytelling to this novel. Her narrative captures the essence of a small town riddled with gossip, secrets, and a facade of being a place where all good people reside.

The book’s resolution, however, leaves readers in suspense. Margot’s confrontation with a key suspect leads to a cliffhanger, with no clear closure provided. This unresolved ending has sparked discussions among readers and hints at the possibility of a sequel.

I think you will find “All Good People Here” to be a gripping murder mystery, one that intertwines the past and present, exploring the impact of a tragic murder on a small community and one woman’s relentless pursuit of the truth. Ashley Flowers’ debut novel is a testament to her storytelling abilities, captivating readers with a complex plot and a haunting reminder of the mysteries that can linger in seemingly peaceful towns.

All Good People Here Main Characters

Margot Davies

The main protagonist, a big-city investigative journalist who returns to her small hometown of Wakarusa, Indiana to care for her sick uncle. As a child, her next-door neighbor and friend January Jacobs was murdered, a case that remains unsolved.


Margot’s uncle who raised her. He is suffering from early-onset dementia.

January Jacobs

Margot’s childhood friend and neighbor who was murdered when Margot was 6 years old. The book flashes back to January’s mother Krissy’s perspective surrounding her death.

Krissy Jacobs

January’s mother. The flashback chapters follow her in months before and after her daughter’s murder, showing her troubled marriage and revealing she knows more about January’s death than she has shared.

Natalie Clark

A five-year-old girl who goes missing in the town next to Margot’s hometown, under eerily similar circumstances to January’s still-unsolved case.


Krissy’s secret lover who wants to protect Krissy at all costs.

Billy Jacobs

January’s abusive stepfather who hates his wife Krissy and believes he should have custody over his children.

Elliott Wallace

A man arrested for Natalie’s disappearance who may have been behind other unsolved crimes and abductions in the area.

All Good People Here Book Review: Themes

One of the most prominent themes in “All Good People Here” is the complexity of motherhood, especially when faced with trauma or a need to protect one’s family. Through January’s mother Krissy, we see the lengths a mother will go to safeguard her child and preserve her family unit, even if it means covering up the truth. Krissy’s choices haunt her for decades and result in ongoing guilt as she mourns January’s death. Even though Krissy had good intentions, her actions had unintended consequences showing how difficult motherhood can be even with the best of intentions.

Another major theme explored is the ripple effect of unsolved cases and cold cases, not just on the town but on the investigators and families connected to the crimes. Margot is haunted into adulthood by her inability to solve January’s murder as a child. The lack of closure for January’s family causes ongoing pain and prevents healing. When Natalie goes missing under similar circumstances over twenty years later, the town is retraumatized. The theme suggests that leaving cases unresolved can cause wounds that never fully mend in communities.

Finally, beneath the theme of the “all good people” in this small friendly town, the book explores the hidden darkness within people and communities. Secrets, affairs, abuse, resentment, and other evils often lurk under the placid veneer of so-called “good people.” The inability of the town to believe evil exists in their midst causes them to overlook clues and prevents justice. This theme challenges the reader to question overly idyllic portrayals of people and places. Ultimately, the book suggests true goodness requires acknowledging and facing the shadows rather than ignoring them.

All Good People Here Writing Style

“All Good People Here” is an engaging and well-crafted novel. From my perspective, Flowers’ background in true crime storytelling is evident in her compelling narrative style, which is both precise and captivating.

One of the most impressive aspects of the book is its intricate plot. The way Flowers interweaves the past and present storylines is particularly noteworthy. The transition between these timelines is seamless, which kept me deeply engrossed in the story. Additionally, the use of multiple perspectives, especially that of January Jacobs’ mother, adds depth and complexity to the narrative.

Flowers’ characterization is another strong point. The characters are well-developed and multidimensional, particularly the protagonist, Margot Davies. Her character’s evolution throughout the story is both believable and engaging. I found myself empathizing with her struggles and rooting for her as she navigated the complexities of the investigation. The portrayal of the small town of Wakarusa, with its myriad of secretive and complex characters, contributes to the book’s immersive experience.

The thematic exploration of the novel is also worth mentioning. Flowers tackles themes such as the impact of unsolved crimes, small-town dynamics, and the pursuit of truth with a deft hand. These themes are woven into the story in a way that is thought-provoking without being overbearing.

However, the novel is not without its drawbacks. The highly ambiguous ending disappointed more than intrigued—without giving solid closure or enough intriguing uncertainty to warrant speculation. For a mystery that built steady intrigue across 300 pages, to abandon the reader at the climax felt like a cursory, abrupt stop rather than a deliberately provocative or stylistic choice.

All Good People Here Book Review: Final Verdict

Ultimately, while All Good People Here doesn’t reinvent the crime fiction genre with lavish literary prose, it triumphs as an engrossing, swift-moving tale guaranteed to grip most mystery devotees. Leveraging her true crime media experience, Flowers succeeds in crafting an addictive page-turner bursting with small town secrets. Though the writing relies on mystery tropes and stereotypes, well-paced action paired with consistent twists make the story a propulsive thrill ride from start to finish.

Devout true crime fans, especially those already familiar with podcaster Flowers’ work, comprise the obvious target audience. However, with two interwoven cases spanning twenty-five years, this mystery contains enough meaty complexity to appeal to a wider demographic seeking an easy-to-binge traditional whodunnit. The book is accessible for the beach read crowd or a flight page-turner, while dropping sufficient clues and surprises to please pickier connoisseurs of crime fiction. While the ending leaves some questions unanswered, the wild plot delivers sufficient escapist intrigue and small-town drama to entertain most mystery lovers seeking a quick, compulsively digestible foray into the genre. For those craving more cracking character portraits or luscious writing, literary fiction this is not—yet it satiates any yen for propulsive, addictive suspense.

Author Profile

Susanna Nicholson
Susanna NicholsonReader, Writer
I spend my days immersed in the world of books, finding solace in their pages. In my spare time, I transform into a critic, penning reviews that unravel the magic and mystery of each story. This passion for reading is not just a hobby; it’s a part of who I am.
Proudly powered by WordPress | Theme: Looks Blog by Crimson Themes.